Last Minute Plymouth Winner Shocks Town in 3-2 Defeat


Town lost 2-3 in what was a pulsating and watchable League One tie against Plymouth Argyle at the County Ground last night. Our first defeat in 6 games in all competitions.

Earlier on Tuesday The Adver reported on Peter Reid’s plan to exploit the flanks and cause the narrow Town midfield plenty of problems. This seems an obvious approach to provide our midfield diamond with problems, and the opening half hour was dominated by our inability to respond to their wide threat. So much so, this tactical advantage contributed to Plymouth’s early goalrush and plenty of other real chances… they could have scored 4 or 5.

Wilson only changed the midfield 4 to a flatter formation, with JP McGovern switched to the left side, after 30 minutes of the first half gone. Fortunately, it was after this tactical change that Town started to deal with Plymouth and create a few chances, however the damage had already been done.

Despite the initial Plymouth width advantage, Town’s early defending looked much to be desired and should have dealt with both Plymouth opportunities that resulted in goals.

First it was goalkeeper David Lucas who was squarely at fault as he failed miserably to meet a long throw from Kari Arnason and Reda Johnson rose above to head the ball with little challenge into an empty net. Those Town fans who’ve seen Lucas’ recent poor composure, decision making and control of his penalty area as displayed at Walsall would be very concerned about the erratic form of the Town no.1 which has directly resulted in 2 goals conceded in 3 games.

Of course I can and should blame Lucas for his error, but rightly I must also point out the many excellent saves he made from close-up and long range throughout the match which kept the scoreline semi-decent and us in the match. Like I said, it could have been 4 or 5 to Plymouth.

Plymouth’s second came shortly afterwards with only 4 minutes between the goals. It came from the first of two pinpoint crosses from the left side – the second would turn the game completely later in the game – where Lucas was beaten and the covering Douglas was caught in two minds and couldn’t clear, Bradley Wright-Phillips pinched a second.

David Prutton has been rightfully singled out this season by myself and others as a weak link in the Town midfield, however I’ve come to realise this has been as much the fault of Wilson who had failed to get Prutton and Douglas to work together in a 2 man central pairing. Last night was perhaps Prutton’s best performance in a Town shirt, albeit later his game was tarnished with a second deserved booking with 14 minutes left to play.

When you are trailing 2 goals behind you need some magic, a goal from out of nowhere to turn the game. It was Prutton who provided this goal and the impetus to spur us forward in the 37rd minute when a full 25 yards out he tried his luck and found the far corner of Romain Larrieu’s net.

From then on the game  swung in Town’s favour with chances either side of half time for Pericard, Dossevi and Rose, who got the deserved equaliser to curl in a well placed free kick at the Town End from 25 yards. I can’t remember when I’ve seen 2 Town goals from 25 yards in one game!

With the game standing at 2-2 it was anyone’s, but perhaps a draw was the ‘deserved’ result for both teams.

No team can account for the the outstanding pinpoint cross from Noone, again from the left, and well-placed header that secured the third goal and the 3 points for Plymouth.

The irony in the Plymouth winner was that it arrived in the 96th minute. The fourth official had only indicated a minimum of 5 minutes added time, concurrent with the decision to give Reda Johnson his marching orders for his second booking. To say Johnson left the pitch slowly is an understatement! The referee didn’t rush him and indicated by looking and pointing at his watch that he would be adding on additional time to compensate for the wastage…that was ultimately profitable for Plymouth in the time added on at the end. But clearly the more pressing question is why we could build on our obvious advantage going into those last 6 minutes?


  • Just returned to London after both home games and feel that 3 points from both games was probably fair.
    Hudderfield second half was the best performance for at least six months, but i feared the small squad would find us out against Plymouth. If Dossevi decides to go to Togo this weekend our lack of strike force options will be exposed at Redbridge.
    I think comment should be made on O’brien whose presence last night meant that we were effectively down to nine men after Pruttons dismissal. Lack of skill should never be criticised but lack of commitment should have no place in the club.
    Agree with you that Smiths form this season should earn him a return on Saturday.


    • I agree, Alan O’Brien certainly didn’t get involved at all last night, although I would only blame Alan in-part for his display.

      There were several occasions when Rose, Prutton and Ferry could have looked up and played a ball forward into open space for Alan to run onto, however they didn’t. They were always looking to play to foot or were just aimlessly running into congested areas and lost the ball.

      Nonetheless… even if Alan had received a through-ball I seriously doubt whether he could have crossed into the box for Pericard / Dossevi in a similar quality and accuracy that Noone provided for Plymouth.


  • Pingback: 2010 STFC Review: September « THE WASHBAG | Swindon Town Blog

Comment Here...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s